Study register · detail
Mixed
GRADE
Moderate
228 citations
Samplen = 241 Pat.
ControlNon-smoking control group
EndpointHistopathological mucosal…
Blindingeinfachblind
DesignObservationelle Kohortenstudie (Bronchoskopie + Biopsie)
Routeinhalativ
Key finding
Cannabis and tobacco cause additive bronchial mucosal damage, whereas cocaine alone produces lesser changes, but intensifies tobacco-induced damage.
Summary
Cohort study (n=241) with bronchoscopy biopsies; cannabis smokers (n=40) showed significantly more histopathological mucosal changes than non-smokers in all 11 characteristics (p≤0,02); cannabis use and tobacco smoking show additive bronchial mucosal damage (MTS group); cocaine alone causes fewer changes than cannabis.
P
PopulationHabitual smokers (cocaine, cannabis, tobacco) as well as non-smoking controls; n=241 (53 non-smokers, 14 cocaine only, 40 cannabis only, 31 tobacco only, 16 cocaine+cannabis, 12 cocaine+tobacco, 44 cannabis+tobacco, 31 all three)
I
InterventionHabitual smoking of crack cocaine, cannabis and/or tobacco (alone or in combination)
C
ControlNon-smoking control group (n=53)
O
OutcomeCannabis and tobacco smokers showed significantly more frequent histopathological changes than non-smokers (p≤0,02 for most characteristics); cocaine alone was significant in only 3 of 11 characteristics (p<0,05); effects of cannabis and tobacco were additive; cocaine intensifies tobacco-associated mucosal damage, but not cannabis-associated damage
Confidence in the evidence
Moderate
The third of four GRADE levels, the effect estimate is probably reliable.
Quality profile
Sample size
★★★★★
Blinding
Single-blind
Effect size
Mixed
Citations / year
★★★★★
Authors
Share
Abstract
<h4>Background</h4>Cannabis and alkaloidal cocaine ("crack") are the two most commonly smoked substances in the United States after tobacco. While regular tobacco smoking has been found to be associated with extensive microscopic alterations in bronchial mucosa, little information is available concerning the effect of crack cocaine and Cannabis on tracheobronchial histopathology.<h4>Study objective</h4>To determine the relative impact of smoked substances (cocaine, Cannabis, and tobacco) alone and in combination on the histopathology of the tracheobronchial mucosa and to assess whether the effects of habitual smoking of two or more substances (cocaine, Cannabis, and/or tobacco) are additive.<h4>Design</h4>Observational cohort study.<h4>Subjects</h4>Fifty-three nonsmoking control subjects (NS), 14 current, habitual smokers of crack cocaine only (CS), 40 current, regular smokers of Cannabis only (MS), 31 regular smokers of tobacco only (TS), 16 current smokers of both cocaine and Cannabis (CMS), 12 current smokers of both cocaine and tobacco (CTS), 44 current smokers of both Cannabis and tobacco (MTS), and 31 current smokers of cocaine, Cannabis, and tobacco (CMTS).<h4>Methods</h4>After preliminary screening evaluation, including a detailed respiratory and general health questionnaire and routine pulmonary function studies, subjects underwent fiberoptic bronchoscopy with endobronchial biopsies of the mucosa of the primary carina and randomly selected secondary or tertiary carinae. Biopsy specimens were processed for light microscopy, stained with hematoxylin-eosin or periodic acid-Schiff, and examined to assess epithelial, basement membrane, and submucosal alterations by one or two pathologists who were masked to the smoking status of the subject.<h4>Results</h4>Smokers of cocaine, Cannabis, or tobacco alone all exhibited more frequent abnormalities than NS in 10 (CS) or all 11 (MS and TS) of the histopathologic features assessed. For most features, MS and TS showed significantly more frequent alterations than NS (p < or = 0.02), while CS showed significantly more frequent abnormalities than NS in only three features (p<0.05) and nearly significant differences from NS in two additional features (p < or = 0.09). Alterations were noted most frequently in CTS (six features) and MTS (three features), while abnormalities were relatively infrequent in CMS. For 10 features, MTS had more frequent alterations than MS and TS. With a single exception, CMTS did not show more frequent alterations than CTS or MTS.<h4>Conclusion</h4>Cannabis and tobacco smoking each produces significant bronchial mucosal histopathology and the effects of Cannabis and tobacco appear additive. Cocaine appears to lead to fewer significant bronchial mucosal alterations than Cannabis or tobacco when smoked alone and does not add to the changes associated with Cannabis. When smoked together with tobacco, however, cocaine appears to augment the bronchial injury caused by tobacco smoking.
The impediment to action advances action.