Study register · detail
Mixed
GRADE
Low
37 citations
Samplen = 9.660 Pat.
EndpointPsychotic experiences
Blindingn.a.
DesignProspektive Zwillingskohortenstudie
Key finding
The covariation between cannabis use and psychotic experiences is predominantly due to shared environmental factors and not genetic influences.
Summary
Population-based twin study (n=4830 pairs, 16-year-olds) on cannabis use in adolescence and psychotic experiences. Cannabis use explains 2-5% of PE variance; association with paranoia and cognitive disorganization fully mediated by shared environmental factors (CE=69-100%). Heritability for cannabis use 37%, for PE 27-54%. Finding relativizes a direct causal cannabis→psychosis pathway in adolescents.
P
PopulationAdolescent twin pairs (16 years old) from the general population, n=4830 pairs (twin cohort study)
I
InterventionCannabis use (self-report: ever used)
O
OutcomeCannabis use explains 2–5 % of the variance in psychotic experiences; shared environmental influences explain the entire covariance between cannabis use and paranoia, cognitive disorganization and parent-reported negative symptoms (bivariate common environment 69–100 %), genetic influences play a role only for hallucinations
Confidence in the evidence
Low
The second of four GRADE levels, the effect estimate is of limited reliability.
Quality profile
Sample size
★★★★★
Blinding
—
Effect size
Mixed
Citations / year
★★★★★
Authors
Share
Abstract
Cannabis users are more likely to have psychotic experiences (PEs). The degree to which these associations are driven by genetic or environmental influences in adolescence is unknown. This study estimated the genetic and environmental contributions to the relationship between cannabis use and PEs. Specific PEs were measured in a community-based twin sample (4830 16-year-old pairs) using self-reports and parent-reports. Adolescents reported on ever using cannabis. Multivariate liability threshold structural equation model-fitting was conducted. Cannabis use was significantly correlated with PEs. Modest heritability (37%), common environmental influences (55%) and unique environment (8%) were found for cannabis use. For PEs, modest heritability (27-54%), unique environmental influences (E=12-50%) and little common environmental influences (11-20%), with the exception of parent-rated Negative Symptoms (42%), were reported. Environmental influences explained all of the covariation between cannabis use and paranoia, cognitive disorganization and parent-rated negative symptoms (bivariate common environment=69-100%, bivariate unique environment=28-31%), whilst the relationship between cannabis use and hallucinations indicated familial influences. Cannabis use explains 2-5% of variance in positive, cognitive, and negative PEs. Cannabis use and psychotic experience co-occur due to environmental factors. Focus on specific environments may reveal why adolescent cannabis use and psychotic experiences tend to 'travel together'.
The impediment to action advances action.