Comparative efficacy and safety of stiripentol, cannabidiol and fenfluramine as first-line add-on therapies for seizures in Dravet syndrome: A network meta-analysis.
Guerrini et al.·Epilepsia OpenImpact 3.1
Clear benefitGRADEHigh27 citations
Samplek = 6 Studien
Durationunclear
ControlPlacebo as well as indirect network…
EndpointMCSF reduction ≥50% from…
Blindingdoppelblind
DesignNetwork Meta-Analyse (Systematische Review)
Cannabinoidcbd
”Key finding
Stiripentol and fenfluramine show similar and superior efficacy compared to cannabidiol in reducing convulsive seizures by ≥50% and ≥75%; stiripentol superior for seizure-free intervals; no significant difference in serious adverse events.
Summary
NMA across 6 RCTs (k=6, 2 each per active substance) on stiripentol, fenfluramine and cannabidiol (10–20 mg/kg/day) as add-on in Dravet syndrome; CBD was statistically inferior to stiripentol and fenfluramine for ≥50% MCSF reduction (p<0.05); stiripentol vs. fenfluramine RD=26% (95% CI: 8%–44%, p<0.01) for seizure freedom; no significant difference in serious adverse events (SAE) between the three active substances.
P
PopulationChildren and adults with Dravet syndrome, pooled data from 6 placebo-controlled RCTs
I
InterventionStiripentol (50 mg/kg/day), fenfluramine (0,7 mg/kg/day), cannabidiol (10 or 20 mg/kg/day) as first-line add-on therapies
C
ControlPlacebo as well as indirect network comparisons between the three active substances
O
OutcomeStiripentol and fenfluramine significantly superior to cannabidiol for ≥50% and ≥75% reduction in monthly convulsive seizure frequency (p<0,05); stiripentol significantly superior to fenfluramine for seizure freedom (RD=26%, 95%-CI: 8–44%, p<0,01); no significant differences in serious adverse events
Confidence in the evidence
Very lowLowModerateHigh
High
The highest of four GRADE levels, the effect estimate is very reliable.
Quality profile
Sample size★★★★★
BlindingDouble-blind
Effect sizeClear benefit
Citations / year★★★★★
Authors
Guerrini R, Chiron C, Vandame D, Linley W, Toward T
Stiripentol, fenfluramine, and cannabidiol are licensed add-on therapies to treat seizures in Dravet Syndrome (DS). There are no direct or indirect comparisons assessing their full licensed dose regimens, across different jurisdictions, as first-line add-on therapies in DS. We conducted a systematic review and frequentist network meta-analysis (NMA) of randomized controlled trial (RCT) data for licensed add-on DS therapies. We compared the proportions of patients experiencing: reductions from baseline in monthly convulsive seizure frequency (MCSF) of ≥50% (clinically meaningful), ≥75% (profound), and 100% (seizure-free); serious adverse events (SAEs); discontinuations due to AEs. We identified relevant data from two placebo-controlled RCTs for each drug. Stiripentol 50 mg/kg/day and fenfluramine 0.7 mg/kg/day had similar efficacy in achieving ≥50% (clinically meaningful) and ≥75% (profound) reductions from baseline in MCSF (absolute risk difference [RD] for stiripentol versus fenfluramine 1% [95% confidence interval: -20% to 22%; p=0.93] and 6% [-15% to 27%; p=0.59], respectively), and both were statistically superior (p<0.05) to licensed dose regimens of cannabidiol (10 or 20 mg/kg/day, with/irrespective of clobazam) for these outcomes. Stiripentol was statistically superior in achieving seizure-free intervals compared to fenfluramine (RD=26% [CI: 8% to 44%; p<0.01]) and licensed dose regimens of cannabidiol. There were no significant differences in the proportions of patients experiencing SAEs. The risk of discontinuations due to AEs was lower for stiripentol, although the stiripentol trials were shorter. This NMA of RCT data indicates stiripentol, as a first-line add-on therapy in DS, is at least as effective as fenfluramine and both are more effective than cannabidiol in reducing convulsive seizures. No significant difference in the incidence of SAEs between the three add-on agents was observed, but stiripentol may have a lower risk of discontinuations due to AEs. These results may inform clinical decision-making and the continued development of guidelines for the treatment of people with DS.